Tags
alabama-history, Cherokee County Alabama History, cherokee-indians, Etowah County Alabama History, northeast-alabama-history, turkeytown
More about the settler Gideon E. Coats. Margaret (Peggy) Lasley Vann Coats went west in the year 1838. This was just before the roundup of the Cherokee People that led to the Trail of Tears. Gideon E. Coats stayed in Alabama. Peggy sent her nephew back to Alabama to retrieve her personal property, including a slave. Gideon Coats refused to allow that.
Gideon Coats filed for a divorce in Blount County in 1842. Peggy did not come back to Alabama to represent herself. The State of Alabama did that. The case was placed on hold in 1842 and 1843. In 1844, it returned to the docket. From the Court Records.
June term 1844

9. Gideon Coats vs Peggy Coats and the Attorney General of the State of Alabama
Bill for divorce
In this case the complainant failing to appear and prosecute his suit according to the law and the rules of this county. It is ordered adjudged and decreed by the court that the bill be dismissed for want of prosecution and that the said Complainant pay the costs to be Taxed by the Register.1
The case is now dismissed. Margaret (Peggy) has moved on to a new beginning in the Indian Territory. Gideon moves on to a new beginning in Alabama.
New Beginning
Alabama must not have wanted to deal with a Cherokee Nation marriage by waiting so long to bring it to the docket for closure.
Gideon homesteaded property, and he purchased a large amount of land. He applied for land patents of now public lands. At the purchased price of $1.25 per acre, the following properties in Cherokee (now Etowah) County, Alabama, were bought.2
| Date | Twp-Rng | Aliquots | Sec | Acres |
| 01 May 1845 | 11S 7E | W ½ SE ¼ | 26 | 78.12 ** |
| 01 June 1845 | 11S 7E | NE ¼ SW ¼ | 26 | 53 |
| 01 Oct 1845 | 11S 7E | NW ¼ SE ¼ | 26 | 39.87 |
| 02 Sept 1850 | 11S 7E | SE ¼ SE ¼ | 26 | 39.87 |
| 01 Nov 1853 | 11S 7E | SW ¼ | 24 | 159.12 |
| 10 March 1884 | 11S 7E | E ½ NW ¼ | 25 | 160.12 |
**This tract is listed in the tract book as P.E ’38, which should be “Pre-Emption” 1838, or taken possession of; also, it shows in the tract book a date purchased as 07 Nov 1842. To purchase land from public sale by the U.S. government in 1840, you had to homestead on the property for two years. Is this the property validated in the Cherokee Indian claim listed as “Gideon E. Coats’ claim”? This is the land in which he built a “Plantation” house. In total, by 1853, Gideon will patent 369.98 acres. By 1884, he will patent the other 160.12 acres, which brings the total to 530.18 acres. However, from land abstracts of his and his family’s properties, he will end up with a lot more.
During the year 1842, he married Sarah Penn (daughter of William Warren and Marian Mourning Sullins Penn). His Indian marriage with Peggy Lasley was still pending divorce separation in Blount County, Alabama. Gideon must have hidden this from the family. The interviews with the descendants show that no one knew of the Cherokee marriage. Gideon and Sarah’s first child was born in 1842. William S. Coats. He died during the Civil War. He was a member of Co. I 10th Al Inf CSA, reported missing May 12, 1864, presumed dead. Listed as captured. (Confederate Service Records, Fold3.com)

On the initial land in Township 11 South, Range 7 East, Section 26, Gideon built the “Plantation” house.

Sarah Coats (mother of Gideon, a widow) has a Pre-Emption date of 1841 of 157.61 acres adjoining Gideon’s property. This is listed in the BLM GLO Records as 11S 7E NW ¼ plus sec “A” all in section 26, purchase date of 04 March 1843. Sarah also patents 39.93 acres section 23, NE ¼ SE ¼, purchase date 28 Aug 1847. She has a total of 197.54 acres. By 1860 Gideon owns all of this and his mother is living with him. 3
Gideon’s brother John M Coats who must have come with him to Turkey’s Town, patents 40 acres in 11S 8E SE ¼ of SW ¼ in Section 19. The patent entry is on 10 November 1846.4 He sells this to his brother Sion Coats Jr. by 1850, and Elizabeth (widow of Sion Jr.) will sell this to Gideon and Pleasant Harbour (a sister, Rebecca Coats’ husband) in 1857. Sion Jr. died in 1857. Gideon and Pleasant Harbour will sell this property to Andrew Jackson Prater on 31 June 1869. 5 We have evidence of John M. Coats’ presence in Turkey’s Town as early as 1837 by signing several affidavits with his brother; yet, he disappears from records. He is not on the 1840, and 1850 US census in Cherokee County. He is not on the Kershaw County, South Carolina census either. He may have died, and there is no record of a marriage. Genealogists believe there is a tombstone in Etowah County, Alabama. This researcher has not found a grave. A two-story hand-hewn log home still stands and is occupied today (2026) on his property. Was this structure there when John purchased the property, or did John build it, or did Andrew Jackson Prater build it? Records of when the log house was built do not exist.
John M. Coats’ property has connections. It is connected to Gadsden, Alabama. Andrew Jackson Prater would purchase adjoining property to create a very large farm of several hundred acres. It would be referred to as Prater’s Springs. This is where gatherings would take place for the community. The property would be purchased by William Marion Meeks in 1894. His son Herbert Meeks would use part of this farm to run his business the Dixie Stock Farm.6
William M. Meeks, a newspaper man born in Floyd County, GA, raised in Centre, AL, purchased the Gadsden Times in 1871 and merged it with the Gadsden News. This would become the Gadsden Daily Times and News. The family published the Gadsden Times News until 1927, even after William Meeks died in 1906. The family would sell the farm in 1927 to the S. M. McGlathery family.7
More Coats Family
Sion Coats Jr. (Gideon’s half-brother) patented 106.25 acres in NE parcel fraction “A” section 19 of 11S 8E, patent entry 1841, purchase date 21 November 1842, and patented 40 acres in SW ¼ SW ¼ of section 19. Total of 146.25 acres. Sion died on 3 October 1857. His wife, Elizabeth, will sell this property to Gideon and Pleasant Harbour.8
In the 1860 Cherokee County, Alabama, US Census, Elizabeth (Sion Jr.’s widow) is living with Christopher A. Hood and his family. Christopher Hood is married to Mary Jane Darrow. Mary Jane is Mary Coats and Christopher C. Darrow’s daughter. Mary Coats is the sister of Gideon Coats. In the 1860 census, the Hoods lived next door to Mary Coats Darrow, a widow. Their residence is on Gideon’s property. A family cemetery is on this property. Christopher Darrow, Mary Coats Darrow, Erastus J. Darrow (their son), Sion Coats Jr., and Austin P. Coats (his son) are buried here. Most likely Elizabeth (Sion’s wife) and possible mother Sarah are buried here, but it is not proven. There are several graves at this site. The family removed their readable tombstones to Lebanon Advent Cemetery in Coats’ Bend with Gideon’s family in 2005 for preservation purposes.

Mary Coats (sister to Gideon) who married Christopher C. Darrow, patented 79.89 acres with Pleasant W. Harbour, who is married to Rebecca Coats (sister to Mary and Gideon); the Pre-Emption date is 1840, and the purchase date is 3 April 1843. This is in 11S 7E, section 23 SW ¼. Christopher and Mary also patented 39.93 acres SE ¼ NW ¼ of section 23 as well as 23.93 acres in section 27 with Levi W. Lawler, NE ¼ NE ¼. The property in section 23 was sold to Gideon by 1877. Christopher was an entrepreneur operating a clothing store/tailor in Coats’ Bend (1850 US Census record). Christopher Darrow died in 1855.9 Most of this family will move to Texas after the death of Christopher and Mary. One of their sons, Erastus J. Darrow, will become one of the largest entrepreneurs in Coats’ Bend. He was raised by his sister Mary J. Darrow Hood Wilkins. 10 He owns part of Gideon’s property, which is beside the Baptist Church (present-day Macedonia Baptist Church). It is here that he will have a trading post/mercantile store in Coats’ Bend. Several Gadsden Daily Times News articles speak about Erastus Darrow, his store, and his hospitality to the community. He was very popular with Christmas parties.
Rebecca Coats (sister to Gideon) married Pleasant W. Harbour; they patented 39.93 acres SE ¼ SW ¼ and 39.93 acres in SW ¼ SE ¼ all in section 23 11 S 7E. They shared the above listing with Christopher Darrow. Also, they patented 162.37 acres in 12S 10E section 18 SW ¼; the patent entry is 1841.11 This is what would become the Goshen Valley community in Cherokee County, Alabama. This is also where they lived. They are buried in the Goshen Valley Cemetery.12
Elizabeth Coats (called Betsey, sister of Gideon) was born in 1810 (never married) and moved to Alabama. She must have lived with Gideon or her mother Sarah. 1860 Cherokee County census records show Elizabeth Coats, age 50, living with her brother Gideon Coats. From the Shortnacy family records and research on Elizabeth, she had a mulatto child in March 1827, fathered by a slave in Kershaw County, S.C. The 1850 Cherokee County census record lists John Shortnacy, 49, from Ireland. He is living two doors from Gideon Coats. His occupation is Ditcher; his wife is Martha, 29, born in South Carolina (mulatto child of Elizabeth). The family states that John changed his name from Shawn O’Shaughnessy to John Franklin Shortnacy.13 Notes from the trackbook BLM GLO Records show Gideon Coats purchasing land in 11S 7E SW ¼ of section 24 on 22 January 1850 159.12 acres and it was deeded to John Shortnacy on 23 January 1850. Gideon purchased this property back by 1870.
Richard Penn, the brother of Sarah Penn, patented on 7 December 1849 40 acres in SW ¼ SE ¼ section 25 11S 7E, and Gideon will purchase this property.14

One can see how the name of Coats’ Bend started. This family owned a great portion of the land. But not 5000 arces. Still more to this story.

- G Coats vs P Coats 1844 Blount Co AL Chancery Court Records MB Book A, page 32, Image 1033, FamilySearch website, https://www.familysearch.org/ark:/61903/3:1:3Q9M-C3SD-5T25?view=fullText&keywords=Gideon+Coats%2CAlabama&searchForm=advanced&lang=en. ↩︎
- https://glorecords.blm.gov/search/ ↩︎
- Ibid, US Census records 1860 and 1850 and 1860 US nonpopulated agricultural schedule, ancestry.com, ↩︎
- https://glorecords.blm.gov/search/ ↩︎
- Land Abstract, Etowah County, Alabama Abstract Company, Copy of Abstract owned by this researcher. ↩︎
- Ibid, Gadsden Daily Times News ↩︎
- Ibid, William Marion Meeks, Northern Alabama Historical and Biographical, Birmingham, Alabama, 1888, Smith, and DeLand ↩︎
- Land Abstract, Etowah County, Alabama Abstract Company, Copy of Abstract owned by this researcher. ↩︎
- Ibid, ttps://glorecords.blm.gov/search/ ↩︎
- Mary Darrow’s will, Etowah County Probate record, Etowah County, AL, 1870 census Record ↩︎
- ttps://glorecords.blm.gov/search/ ↩︎
- Goshen Valley Cemetery. Also known as Goshen Cemetery, Livley Cemetery, Cherokee County, Alabama, USA, https://www.findagrave.com/cemetery/1413181/goshen-valley-cemetery ↩︎
- Family information from notes of Johnny Thornton and Deborah Morgan [Steel, Al, Shortnacy descendant] ↩︎
- ttps://glorecords.blm.gov/search ↩︎
Trust in the Lord with all your heart, and do not rely on your own understanding; in all your ways know him, and he will make your paths straight. Proverbs 3: 5-6 CSV







